After a group of teens visits a dangerous island where three are left behind, the surviving girls realize they must return to confront the sinister force hunting them. This dark YA thriller is perfect for fans of Yellowjackets.
Eight were lost. Five were found. None will ever be free.
For Evie Williams, life is about to get a lot more complicated. Haunted by the events of a school trip to Hollow Lake National Park that went disastrously wrong, Evie and her friends returned changed, their lives forever marked by the mysterious Island they encountered—and the three girls they left behind.
Now, someone is picking off those who were involved, one by one. Their families, friends, and even online investigators are all caught in a deadly game. The stakes are raised when Evie receives a chilling to save her loved ones, she must return to the Island.
As Evie and the other "Lost Girls" navigate the treacherous terrain of the Island once more, they must confront the secrets they’ve buried, the horrors they witnessed, and the person—or thing—that’s hunting them. But some secrets refuse to stay hidden, and the Island demands a price for freedom.
Rebekah Faubion's debut, Lost Girls of Hollow Lake was a chilling supernatural thriller that has so many twists and turns and deadly intrigue that it was hard not to devour this book in one go! I nearly would've if I started this earlier than I did! Lol.
I'm always up for a good YA thriller and if there's a supernatural twist, I am even more intrigued! I've never seen an episode of Yellow Jackets, so I can't speak to how the comparison of that works with this one. That being said, I definitely got a bit of LOST and The Lord of the Flies vibes going on. Not explicit comparisons but the vibes were definitely ringing true!
Evie is our heroine and she was one of five survivors when eight girls went missing on an island that no one can see...or at least that not everyone can see. That part itself was trippy, and very resonate with LOST too! Evie and a class of students were doing extra credit type activities in the woods across from this mysterious island and when all of the girls in her cabin could see it, they decide to sneak out at night and "visit" it, because why not? But honestly, with all the local legends and horror stories surrounding this island, why would you want to? But that's just me!
The girls end up getting lost for nearly a month. They can't tell if they made it to the mysterious island or if they are still on the mainland. It's foggy and their sense of direction is cloudy, so they are essentially stuck on a creepy island where creepy things are seen and felt.
The book largely takes place in present day which is few months after the girls made it home. We are treated to alternating chapters that show us what happened during that time and it's essentially whackado! It's so bizarre and confounding, but it does eventually paint an eerie picture.
Back in the present day, however, people connected to the incident are being murdered. We even get excerpts of seeing this happen which is always surreal! But when the evidence points to one of the missing and confirmed dead girls being the possible culprit, Evie isn't convinced, but it's clear someone connected to what happened to them might be behind these grisly murders.
This was quite the chilling tale! It's got definitely slasher vibes when it came to the murdery bits. Like any YA thriller, there is a thread of romance between Evie and one of the girls, but the romantic interludes were sparse, which is my preference when it comes to thrillers. There's a psychotic killer on the loose, now's not the time to make out! Lol.
I do want to forewarn any fellow animal readers out there, there is a dog in here who is loyal to a fault to Evie. The sweetest and most protective dog. But Rebekah herself has an animal menagerie as said in her bio, so you can deduce how she will do things when things happen. I did not need tissues, so take faith in that!
All in all, Lost Girls of Hollow Lake was a chilling supernatural thriller with an eerie mystery to it. The murderous rampage of the killer made it a struggle to figure out whodunit, but the answer made sense in the end...in its own way! Needless to say, I didn't figure it out this go around, but that's just as exciting as figuring out sometimes! Lol. If you're looking for a creepy read for when you go camping (or just anytime!) be sure to check this one out!
Overall Rating 4/5 stars











































